Deck Stain Reviews Ratings
Deck Stain Reviews Ratings
Deck Stain Reviews Ratings
We Would Love to Hear From You!
Please post a review in the Consumer Star Ratings Below.
The Comment Area Below is for in-depth reviews and any questions you may have!

Thompson’s WaterSeal Finish Review2.18/5(29)

Thompson's WaterSeal

Thompson’s WaterSeal

Thompson’s® WaterSeal® Waterproofer Plus Clear Wood Protector is designed for all exterior wood and decking surfaces. This protection includes: Water repellency, prevents water damage, maintains natural wood grain, all while resiting mold growth. Thompson’s® WaterSeal® claim to fame is the ability to waterproof your exterior wood.

We tested the Thompson’s® WaterSeal® in the Clear finish.

Thompson’s® WaterSeal® Scores (1-10)

Appearance After Initial Stain Application: 8

- The Thompson’s® WaterSeal® Clear did not alter or change the appearance of the wood. After full drying we tested the ability to repel water. Water did bead on top of the finish and did not absorb into the wood.

Preventing UV Graying at 2 Year Mark: 1

- As far as we can tell, Thompson’s® WaterSeal® does not prevent UV graying at all. This is a huge disappointment as preventing UV graying is the number one reason to stain your exterior wood and decking.

Wear/Tear and Peeling: 8

- Thompson’s® WaterSeal® penetrates deep into the wood. There was no peeling or wearing. We would have given it a 10 if  the product still repelled water but it did not.

Cost Per Square Foot: 9

- Thompson’s® WaterSeal® is a very inexpensive product to purchase and coverage is exceptional. Unfortunately the saying “you get what your pay for” applies here as the Thompson’s® WaterSeal® offers no UV protection whatsoever.

Preventing Mold/Mildew/Algae: 1

- After 2 years the entire deck was covered in black mold. It seems that the oils used in Thompson’s® WaterSeal® feed and promotes the growth of mold spores.

Ease of Application: 9

- Since this is a clear product, Thompson’s® WaterSeal® applies extremely easy without the need to back wipe. Just apply with a pump sprayer or stain pad. This finish does not show overlap marks.

Color Shifting (darkening) after 2 Years: 7

- We would say that the Thompson’s® darkens in color since there was a good amount of mold growing in the finish.

Difficulty of Reapplication: 6

- A heavy cleaning would be needed to remove all the graying and mold from the surface.

Overall Score Thompson’s® WaterSeal® at 2 Year Period: 6.125

- Overall Thompson’s® WaterSeal® Clear Plus wood finish is a “clear” disappointment. Any finish that offers zero ability to prevent UV graying should not be considered for your deck or exterior wood.

Product Information:

Cost: $19.99 per Gallon
Stain Type: Clear Water Repellent
Available Colors: Clear
Application Temperature: 45-95 F
Coats Required: 1 coat for most scenarios
Coverage Per Gallon: 200-300 Square Feet
Application Tools: Sprayer, Pad, Brush, Roller
Dry Time: 48 Hours
Cleanup: Mineral Spirits
VOC Compliant: 250 Compliant in all States
More Info: Product Data
Manufacturer: Thompson’s

Test Deck Stats:

When Tested: May 2007
Deck Wood Type: Teak Decking
Deck Square Footage: 400 Square feet
UV Exposure: Full sun
How Many Years Tested: 2 Years
Stain Color Used:

*All products tested and results are from our experience. We offer no guarantee of similar results. Take inconsideration that results may differ due to different wood types, exposure to UV radiation, and natural weathering.

Consumer Star Ratings - Please Rate Your Experience With This Product

-Please only Rate if Used Product! (5 Star=Excellent - 1 Star=Poor)

-You may also post comments or ask questions below.

129 Responses to “Thompson’s WaterSeal Finish Review”

  1. Sean says:

    My name is Sean. I live in Westbury NY. I have a pressure treated wood deck that is at least 30 + years. It was always maintained by your products. But given its age I new it was time to rebuild. As I started the demo I noticed the bottom of the deck boards were in good condition. So I decided to flip and recut the old boards and only replace what I needed. I used your cleaning product when I was done. I was very happy with the results. I decided to let the wood dry and fade for a year. About a month ago I was in the homedepo in East meadow NY were I had the pleasure of meeting one of your sales reps. He introduced himself as Rick, and asked me if I had any questions. I proceeded to tell him my story. He seemed very interested. Then in a Boston accent he explained the difference in the various types of stains and clear. While we were talking I find out he is from the cape code area. Well after a great conversation about building and refurbishment of decks I had to leave to go make a call to the higher powers(my mother and my wife) . Well I won. I took a chance and brought Thompson water seal stain color maple. Your product was so simple and a pleasure to use. I would like to give Mr Rick from Boston and Thompson water seal a great round of applause. People come to the house and think all the wood is new. When I tell them what Boston Rick recommend and what I did there amazed. Thank you Thompson your vender Boston Rick. Sincerely Sean C. PS Boston Rick I hope your home project comes out as nice as mine if not better. THANK YOu

  2. Ken Ridge says:

    I have sent an email to Thompson's to verify a possible change in formula, but am posting this to make readers aware that it appears there has a been a change in in the formula for THOMPSON'S WATER SEAL Waterproofer PLUS Clear Wood Protector.

    From viewing the MSDS information, it appears the "newer" formula (model 2180-) has a much higher percentage (close to 100%) of paraffin oil than the "older" formula (model 1180-). There also appears to be a noticeable difference in consistency, with the older formula have a more oily clearer appearance, and the new formula being thicker.

    At this point, I don't know how this might effect performance, but possibly DeckStainHelp can comment.

    • Rob says:

      Noticed a major difference in the old and new product. Sprayed 3/4 of my deck with old formula with no problem at all. Bought new product and can't spray at all. I can't say how "new" product will protect because I can't applied.

  3. mary says:

    Thompson water seal is turning to gel. IS THERE ANY WAY TO BRING IT BACK TO ORIGINAL TEXTURE?

  4. Joseph says:

    Worst water sealer I have ever used.. Water based water repellent? ? It repels itself and looks horrible

  5. Worried in NC says:

    We bought a new, stained wood, deck furniture set at a Mennonite farm store that makes high-end furniture and outbuildings. The store manager told us to apply Thompson's Water Seal Clear Multi-Surface Waterproofer to protect the set. I tried to spray it on and it beaded up and puddled so I brushed on a thin coat. That was five days ago and it is still tacky. I even brought a small bench inside to see if it would dry better in the house. No difference. I am concerned that the Thompson's product just ruined $450 worth of deck furniture!

  6. Mary says:

    Someone please help! I went to our local home Depot because we wanted to redo our deck it's not a stained deck but a painted one instead. We were told to purchase a certain type of paint and told to top it off with Thompsons waterproofing and clear wood protector once the paint had dried, omg what a mess it's still wet after 5 days and worse the parts that are somewhat dry are beyond slippery. We went back to home Depot and we were just told they made a mistake and that we need to repaint the deck again, that that is the only way to remove the slip. Is this true? Is there anything else we can do?

  7. Frank says:

    I've used Thompson's Plus Wood Protector on a pressure treated pine deck for the last 10-12 years (2 applications with same product). I mix 2 parts Tinted Natural Cedar with 1 part Clear to obtain color darkness I want (to make knots in wood less obvious without loosing grain look). I checked with manufacturer and they said that's OK as both are made with same formula. Deck exposure is partial sun (high noon). I typically reapply every 5 years (probably should do it every 4 years), or when deck appears to need it. I have never experienced any mold issues. Gradually looses it's color tint luster, but then no sealer lasts forever. I use a bio-deck cleaner with a pressure washer to lift out dirt that is absorbed into the wood over time. Never any issues with peeling, gumyness, it applies easily, good cleanup with pump sprayer and brush. It is water based product and drying time is a couple days. You need to let "new" wood to cure for 30 days before sealing. If you want a pristine looking deck that doesn't need periodic maintenance, then suggest you go with a composite deck. Otherwise from what I've read, full direct sun exposure needs sealer every year or 2, and partial sun (half day) every 4 years. My deck is original 1972ish, lived there for going on 20 years, and only replaced about 10-15% of 2×4 decking 4 years ago. Note that I live in Chicago area, and not in Arizona or Florida climate. Ahhh, the beauty of real wood.

  8. Randy says:

    Our deck gets full afternoon sun, and this is just an OK product, not great. It lasts about 1.5 years then the wood darkens and the mold comes back. You definitely have to power wash because a deck cleaner won't get it clean enough.

  9. Duane says:

    Full sun. Spent 20,000.00 for new deck after the six month mark the deck was in full gray..

  10. Cindy says:

    This is the first time I've ever felt compelled to write an online complaint, but I am so disappointed with this product, that I shall add my name to the list here. Sadly, I found this review page AFTER using the waterseal. I followed the directions exactly–and even viewed their youtube video to make sure I applied it properly. Three days later we still have an oily deck. I contacted the company and was told that I must have used "a slight bit too much." Now they "recommend cleaning the deck with a degreaser." I hope others check this site BEFORE investing in Thompson's.

  11. Big Wyll says:

    I have a six month old deck that I am going to stain for the first time. After 4 months in the hottest summer ever a few boards warped very badly. I have tried a few sample cans from the local hardward store on the warped boards that were removed. I decided that Thompsons clear water seal gave me the look I was looking for. All the other stains tested were semi transparent but the tint removied the natural look of the wood. Even the clear stain had a tint to it. I later learned that the tint is for UV protection. My question is, what product should I use that will give me a true clear finish and protect from mold? Also, does applying a second coat of Thompsons offer better protection against mold? I asked this because I tried both one coat and a second on separate boards.

    • Bill, look at a different brand as Thompson\’s does not do so well with mold. If you want a true clear (no uv protection) and good mold prevention, then you would want the Defy Extreme Clear.

  12. Deborah Veach says:

    Stained back porch and front deck this year in May with Nutmeg Brown solid……it is terrible…both have pealed so badly we are now in September having to re-do both of them….this product is terrible especially for $24.99 a gallon and we used 5 gallons.would NOT recommend to anyone…and neither one had been previously stained or painted the front de k was seasoned wood approx 4 years and the back porch approx 2 years so that is not the issue….Very,Very, dissatisfied and unhappy!

  13. e. p says:

    used this product before, i have to use it every year because the water beading doesnt work after that. power washed my de cks have 2 decks , the wood looked great the grain looked awsome put thompsons clear on and it did not bring the grain out looks darker and has a milkey finish where the roller streaks were what other product can i use over itto bring the grain back out and maybe a little shine to it help

  14. Mike says:

    Used Thompson Harvest Gold on old weathered graying privacy fence, looks great, easily applied and used less than most stains stated their product would take. Used Thompson Sequoia Red on a new deck, six weeks old, easily applied, looks great and dries quickly. Thompson wood protector with stain is one of the best, easiest products I have used on wood products and I have worked with wood for 40 plus years.

  15. Carolyn says:

    I ratededs graying and wear and tear at 2 because I have only a short time experience with this stain, but I made this rating because I am sooooooo unhappy with the color. I used the semi-transparent cedar tint, and I now have an ORANGE deck. It is repelling water, and that is good, but the color is absolutely horrible. I hope it wears off, but even if it does, that color will be stuck in all those out-of-the-traffic-pattern, out-of-the-sun places for a long time. I have a beautiful natural cedar ceiling on my deck with a hideous ORANGE pine floor and railing. We did allow the wood to cure before applying the Thompson's.

  16. David Bryan says:

    Should I seal my wood before I build my gate or deck?

  17. Sarlin Construction says:

    We applied this on a new deck, 5 months after it was built. With the first heavy rain it mildewed. I called Thompsons and they seemed to feel this was normal. I now am going to remove the Thompsons product, they are sending me the remover but labor is at my expense. I am sorry I ever used their product and as a home builder I will not use anything from them or Sherwin Williams, the parent company again.

Leave a Reply

as of August 2015
  • 19,000+ Questions, Answers, and Consumer Reviews
  • 150+ Help Articles and Reviews
  • 3000+ Forum Help Posts
  • 1300+ Consumer Star Ratings

Find Products?

Manufacturers and Websites:
...See All Product Websites


*This is first and foremost a help site from our experience as wood restoration contractors. All stain and prepping manufacturer directions were followed with our reviews and ratings. We offer no guarantee of similar results. Take inconsideration that wood and deck stain results may differ due to prepping procedures, different wood types, exposure to UV radiation, natural weathering, etc.