How To Change from Water Based to Oil Based Deck Stains 4.7/5 (69)

This post was updated on May 2, 2022

Change from Water Based to Oil Based Deck Stains

DeckStainHelp.com continues to be a trusted source for the latest in deck restoration news and trending topics throughout 2022. Water-based stains and oil-based stains have their advantages and disadvantages. If you wish to change from a water-based to oil-based deck stain, or vice versa, here are some suggestions. Any questions? Ask below!


How to Change From Water Based to Oil Based Exterior Decking Stain and Vice Versa

The longevity of a deck or other exterior wood structure depends highly on how well it is maintained. A wood surface left alone or neglected will not last long in a harsh environment. Wood needs to be sealed and protected from moisture, UV rays, mold, mildew, and such contaminants that will cause rot and decay. The most common types of wood protectants are oil and water-based.

Both have their advantages and disadvantages. Once a wood surface is coated with a particular type of stain it is usually maintained every few years with another light maintenance coat of the same type of stain. However, on occasion, some homeowners may decide to change from oil-based to a water-based stain or vice versa.

To do this successfully a few guidelines need to be followed.

When switching from one particular type of stain to another, you have to remember the characteristics of the stains you are working with. These two types of stains will not perform well together. If the wood has a penetrating oil-based stain on it now, a water-based stain will not be able to penetrate the wood. If it is film-forming stains you are dealing with, they will not adhere well and normally the topcoat stain will fail prematurely.

To successfully change from oil-based to water-based or vice versa, you have to remove all of the existing stain. There are products like Restore-A-Deck Stain Stripper that can help break down existing stains to make them easier to remove. The stripper is applied to the wood surface and allowed to dwell. It works to soften the stain so the wood surface can then be pressure washed or scrubbed clean. The second step of a wood brightener is then applied to neutralize the stripper and prepare the wood for a new stain.

Removing an old stain and getting back down to bare wood is the only way to ensure the new stain will adhere or penetrate the wood properly. Removing an old stain is not always easy. Solid stains and some water-based stains can be extremely stubborn. They may take several attempts to strip and sanding may be necessary. Once the existing stain is gone you can apply the new oil or water-based stain to a clean wood surface.

Please Ask Any Questions Below


Please Rate This. You may also post comments or ask questions below.

Related Deck Stain Help Articles & Reviews

guest

250 Comments
newest
oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sidne
Sidne
6 months ago

I have a small area of cedar decking that was stained with a semi-transparent water based stain three years ago and has had to be scraped and restained every year since then. I have been able to remove all of the water based stain by using a pressure washer. I think the way to go would be to apply an oil based transparent stain to cut down on the yearly maintenance. Do you agree? Do I need to do anything in the way of prep now that the old stain is off?

Sidne
Sidne
6 months ago

Thank you! Reading elsewhere, I see that I can expect to have to re-stain every two or three years even with the best stain. Does that sound right? Regardless, not having the stain peel would be a worthy goal.

Sidne
Sidne
6 months ago

Many thanks for your help and your quick reply.

Sally
Sally
6 months ago

My deck is my own hell realm. I have a three story southern facing redwood deck. The first stain was suggested by the person who we hired. It was for boats. He said it would last. It started pealing within three months because the wood swelled. Then we paid to have the whole thing sanded and re-stained with a semi-transparent stain in oil based because we were told it lasted longer. We have to re-due it every one to two years. It really didn’t last long here in San Francisco. Now its hard to get oil based stain from the manufacturer unless I go to Nevada to purchase it and it’s not environmentally friendly. Once again what to do. I’m 67 years old and I don’t have the money or the stamina to clean, strip, and add a wood brightener to three stories of decking and stairs before I apply a semi transparent stain. Its too many steps. What I don’t understand is why no one is actually making a water based stain that can be applied to an oil base with out having to start from the beginning. A bridge so to speak between the oil and the water based which seems to be the direction we are all moving given the VOC’s and pollution. The internet is so full of options it is useless. I went to This Old House, and they said you can add water base over oil. Odd because in general you can’t to that. So I’m just not making any progress. My deck seems to be sealed, but faded. Three are only two areas that seem to be worn out on the treads where you see the wood. So essentially a stain is probably not what I could use as the wood is sealed. Because it wouldn’t be able to penetrate. What a confusing mess.

Sally
Sally
6 months ago

Thanks.

I'm A Little Teapot
I'm A Little Teapot
8 months ago

I have a screened porch that has been previously stained with a semi-transparent (I think) stain. I don’t know what type of stain, or how long ago – but probably a very long time based on the rest of the house. We’re getting ready this year to repair and restain it, likely with a solid stain so we can significantly lighten the color. Minimal wear is expected. How do I determine the type of stain that was used? Or can I safely cover with oil or water based, regardless of what is currently there? We’ll be cleaning, but do not plan to completely strip.

pete bennetts
pete bennetts
11 months ago

years ago i used a decking oil on a treated pine deck.Well they called it an oil but its water based so it cant be . I recently replaced parts of the deck and also added bits now i want to paint it to keep it all the same can i use an oil based or turps wash up type paint ? i recently used a brand here in Australia on pavers and a concrete shed that dried really quick and appears to be very hard much harder than a water wash up type paint? i have just tried applying some on a small section that i can easily sand off and it seems to have taken really well cheers for any advice and merry christmas to all

Reza
Reza
1 year ago

How can I change the color of brown solid stain to white color without deck stripper? The brown solid stain has been done recently and it is Behr based 5013.

Reza
Reza
1 year ago

Many thanks for quick response. Wondering if I should use the same brand but white color solid stain or you thing there is a better brand white solid stain to used it.

John L.
John L.
1 year ago

Hello. I stained an outdoor porch with interior stain because I was told I could just use spar urethane to seal it and therefore the stain type wouldn’t matter. When I read the directions on the spar urethane it stated that it was not to be used on outdoor floors. A worker at the local hardware store confirmed this. I do not think the interior stain will provide an appropriate amount of protection from the elements. I thought of putting an exterior timber oil over the interior stain but read that the previously stained wood will not accept the timber oil. Currently, water puddles on the newly stained porch. Most of my porch is covered. The stairs and northwest corner receive most of the rain and sun exposure. What would you suggest? Thanks!

Carol Weide
Carol Weide
1 year ago

We used an oil based transparent stain 4 years ago but the smell was too strong.I want to switch to water based. Is that ok.

Carol Weide
Carol Weide
1 year ago

The man we hired is going to pressure wash it . Is that enough? What about spindles? He’s says hes washing them also . Another question. Is there an oil based deck stain semi transparent that is not overly smelly.

DONNA DONEY
DONNA DONEY
1 year ago

Can you add stain to darken a hybrid deck stain?

Don Matts
Don Matts
1 year ago

Hi. Fantastic Article. Quick question.

If I used an oil based semi-solid stain w/tint 3 years ago. Am I able to use a Water based stain this year? I used various deck cleaners to remove mildew, mold and dirt yesterday. I would like to use the water based if I can but dont want to ruin things. It would be the exact same color. Any thoughts?

Linda
Linda
1 year ago

What is the best clear oil based product for a cedar deck?

Seán Floyd
Seán Floyd
1 year ago

I have a deck stained with General Paint Semi Transparent Latex/Oil coating, our only General Paint supplier in town has closed, can you suggest another compatible stain to use ? We do have a Home Hardware in town,
Thanks, Seán.

Zach
Zach
1 year ago

I stained a new deck after a year of weathering last season. I used RAD 2 step prep and water based stain. After this winter I had a lot of peel up on the horizontal surfaces. How do you recommend I proceed? Power wash to remove the stain that didn’t bond well and then clean and brighten and reapply to even it up the best I can or strip off all of it and try something else? If you recommend stripping will the RAD stripper break down the RAD water based stain?

Ann Watson
Ann Watson
2 years ago

How can I remove tinted Ali’s decking oil as I now want a natural finish?

Steve
Steve
2 years ago

I have been using Olympic maximum semi transparent redwood stain for years. I’m wondering if I can use Olympic Elite solid stain to cover the semi transparent? A lot of the old stain has peeled so I pressure washed it already and used a deck cleaning solution. Thanks for any help

Steve
Steve
2 years ago

One other question can you cover Olympic solid stain with another brand of solid stain down the road ?

Steve
Steve
2 years ago

One other question for future reference, can I use a different brand solid stain over semi transparent or solid stain or do I have to stay with the same brand ? Thanks for the help

Todd
Todd
2 years ago

I have a 12ftx35ft all-wooden deck with approximately 55 feet of wooden railing. The deck is approximately 4-6 years old. I was fairly certain it had never been stained and the deck was definitely at least 1 year old when I stained it last, approximately 2-3 years ago. I read review after review from other websites and it seems there was always conflicting advice (oil vs water based, order of prep, brightener, etc), but no one has as comprehensive of a website and ACTIVE advice as you guys, so thanks for what you do! This is what I tried: Did a deck cleaner, then power washer, then had a ton of fuzzies that looked terrible, so I tried using a combination of a belt sander (roughly 3 inches by 14inch wide belt) and a 6 inch orbital sander to get rid of the fuzzies. It. Was. A nightmare. I used a deck pad applicator and paint brush on each spindle/post/railing. Total time was probably about 30 hours over a few weekends, of course having to redo a step or two because rain forced me to wait (and I have dogs that transit the deck from dog door to back yard while I’m at work). I used Thompsons WaterSeal Timber Oil (Teak). While I loved the color, it did not last long and I did not maintain it the way I should have. There is zero water beading on any horizontal surfaces with 5 second water test. Can’t tell on vertical surfaces but they seem more resistant (and darker). The dogs are very hard on this deck, as you’ll see from pictures. We average about 40 inches of rain a year and about 102 inches of snow. My dogs sometimes pee or poop on the deck. I’ve tried to stop it, but not a lot of luck. My top problems with the deck are: a) It gets INCREDIBLY slippery in wet/snowy weather. So much so that it makes it hard to even snow-blow the deck in winter because tires don’t want to grip. This is worsened by my laziness at promptly cleaning deck of leaves and performing annual cleaning/brightening and annual/semi-annual re-staining. I plan on fixing this in the future. b) Thompson stain seemed to last about a year or less. c) Mold/mildew/Algae grow incredibly fast on the deck even though I try to clear of snow often. I’m looking to do either TWP 1500 (live in NY) Semi Transparent (Rustic) or RAD Water Based Semi-Transparent (Cedar) and definitely leaning more towards the RAD option because trying to line up 2-4 days of no rain, warmer than 50, cooler than 80 or 90 with lower humidity is incredibly hard, especially when it means I have to keep my dogs inside during the process and come back from work to let them out. After reading other reviews and answers, my plan is to strip the deck with RAD, use pressure washer (2800 PSI, 2.3 GPM), apply the brightener from RAD, check for… Read more »

IMG_7588.jpg
IMG_7589.jpg
IMG_7591.jpg
IMG_7590.jpg
Todd
Todd
2 years ago
Reply to  Todd

More Pictures…

IMG_7593.jpg
IMG_7594.jpg
IMG_7595.jpg
IMG_7596.jpg
Todd Hunsicker
Todd Hunsicker
2 years ago

Awesome, thank you. Should I get the stripper booster gel stuff or not necessary?

Todd
Todd
2 years ago

Follow up: I still want to strip and stain my deck but added a new section. I WAS going to just let it season for a year (winter is here in about 2-4 weeks) and then do the entire deck at once, but then a friend said he would definitely not let the deck sit that long because (other than the new part) the deck is already looking dry and we get a ton of snow in the NE.

Two questions:

1) Should I:
A) strip the entire deck, stain the entire deck
B) Strip the entire deck and stain only the seasoned part
C) Strip and stain only the old/seasoned portion?

2) Weather conditions below are not ideal and just barely on the boundary of their recommendations (45-90 degrees surface temperature, “do not apply when deaily low is below 45 degrees or when rain is expected within 12 hours”). Do you think I should:
A) Strip, brighten and stain on Saturday
B) Strip and brighten on Saturday, stain on Sunday at 9-10am as soon as it reaches 45?

TODAY: Raining
SAT: 55 HI, 40LOW 0% chance of rain, 50% humidity at 1pm increasing to 70% humidity over night
SUN: 60 HI, 46LOW 0% chance rain until 8pm, then increasing from 5% at 8pm, then increasing slowly until 47% at 11pm. Humidity starts at 70% early sunday morning, dropping to 50% and staying around 50% until early Monday morning

Deck Picture.jpg
John
John
2 years ago

If I am going over a a solid water based stain that is peeling due to non sticking on a treated wood deck and am going to chemically remove most of the stain and then restain with a darker colour of the same water based stain can I get away without sanding any residue of the old stain without sanding

Jeff Cunningham
Jeff Cunningham
2 years ago

We’re using an acrylic transparent finish, (Behr) on are prepped deck. After several years, when it requires more maintenance, what are the procedures to refurbish it?

Jeff Cunningham
Jeff Cunningham
2 years ago

Thanks. Think I’ll stop and remove what I’ve put on, and go with Thompsons or Olympic clear sealer.

Jeff Cunningham
Jeff Cunningham
2 years ago

Just returned 6gals. of Behr finish. Going with your advice and recommended products on stripper and stain. You’ve been a lifesaver on this matter. Thanks again! Jeff

Paul Yewdall
Paul Yewdall
2 years ago

Hello I am thinking of staining my fence grey then protecting it with oil . Is it best to use water or solvent based stain before applying oil ? Or do I use an oil based stain ? I’ve already purchased the oil top coat as in my experience paint or solvent based finishes don’t last as long as oil

Bill
Bill
2 years ago

I put a water based stain/sealant on my deck and I like the color but wanted to give it more protection…can I apply an oil based sealant (no stain) on top after letting the water based brand dry thoroughly?

John McHale
John McHale
2 years ago

By accident I mixed an oil based stain with and acrylic stain for my cedar deck. Not sure it is going to dry so I am assuming I will have to strip the deck and then give it a sand down and then use a wood brightener and then restain the deck using one or the other of the stains? Any recommendations? Will the deck stripper work if the deck is still tacky and not completely dry?

John McHale
John McHale
2 years ago

I was afraid of that. I think this maybe quite a messy rework to say the least. Live and learn. Thanks for your response I appreciate it.

Ben Trudeau
Ben Trudeau
2 years ago

How to stain brown pressure treated wood White after it has weathered a year?

I’m using SuperDeck transparent waterborne stain, should I apply a primer first ?

Sue
Sue
2 years ago

I have water based clear on my merbeau deck at present and wish to put an oiled based clear on it. The oiled based finish tends to leave the deck with a more shiny look. Am I wrong in thinking this and what preparation would I have to do before using oil based finish

Mike Dimura
Mike Dimura
2 years ago

I have several coats (years) of water base stain on a pressure treaded deck. Can I change to a oil base stain without stripping the deck?

Z z
Z z
2 years ago

Yes. As long as the wood is weathered. Do a splash test….if water beads, strip (powerwash) and sand. Light sand. 220 will do. A wood brightener after this, never hurts. Maybe overkill, but a good process.

If water doesn’t bead. Just stain. Whichever is good, but most are water-modified these days. Will leave a bit of plasticy type finish if overapplied.

Debs
Debs
2 years ago

I used a clear oil on my decking about 2 years ago but don’t know if it was water or solvent based , I want to now use a coloured oil which is solvent based will it be ok to use ?

Tom
Tom
2 years ago

I used a oil based stain over a water based stain. The result is a bubbling appearance on the wood. How can this be corrected?

Elise
Elise
2 years ago

I need to stain/seal some exterior vertical wood and posts that are 13 years old and already have a stain on them. I don’t know what the existing stain is, I didn’t own the house when it was applied. I don’t know if it was water or oil based, and I don’t know if it was semi-transp, semi-solid or solid? I would like to use oil based semi-solid or semi-transparent. I do not want to use solid. How do I know what to use (oil or water) if I don’t know what’s already been used?

Elise
Elise
2 years ago

Here are 2 photos. I’d like to use an oil base semi-transport or semi-solid if possible. Just bought this house, don’t know what’s on it now, but it’s almost all gone.

15A9142B-92C7-4ABF-B27F-7ED4C1BB4BF7.jpeg
ECAED436-8A5B-49F5-992A-DAA999D76190.jpeg
David
David
2 years ago

I currently have water based stain on my deck, can I change to a oil based stain and what is the best way to do it? What is the best oil best stain to use?

Patrick
Patrick
2 years ago

I stuffed my deck up i sanded my deck back not to bear wood. I had waterbase stain originally and then i put oil based on top coming out very patchy could i use a waterbase stain to fix the problem

Stacey
Stacey
3 years ago

We purchased a new home and did a water sealer only on the front porch. We now need to stain the.porch can we use oil based stain?

Paula
Paula
3 years ago

We have wood garage doors that have been stained with Sikkens cetol 1 RE for many years now. Being in Canada oil based products are no longer available. We now are looking at paint, what type of primer do we use & do we have to sand to bare wood?

Paula
Paula
3 years ago

Not in Canada, no oil based stain is available. We are now looking @ painting…do we have to go to bare wood…not looking forward to it?

Sue t
Sue t
3 years ago

i used Olympic acrylic oil semi transparent stain on my decks at least 5 yrs ago, what can I use now?

Sue t
Sue t
3 years ago

Thank you for replying, I have multiple questions. I have 2 decks 22 & 24 yrs old. Is Olympic acrylic oil semi transparent stain an oil based or water based stain? They are in fairly good shape. Will stripping and or sanding damage the older wood? Would it be better to reapply the Olympic stain? Cannot remember what I used originally but it did adhere and was ok.

Sue t
Sue t
3 years ago
Reply to  Sue t

Thank you for reply. I have many questions. I have 2 decks 22 & 24 yrs old. Is Olympic acrylic oil semi transparent oil or water based? Will sanding or stripping damage this older wood? Is it better to reapply the Olympic product again? Algae is an issue because we have many flower pots. Decks are in pretty good shape, but weathered. What product would I use to strip, do not own power washer.

Charlene
Charlene
3 years ago

I am considering Sikkens oil based deck stain. If I experience traffic spots can the stain simply be reapplied in the future?

Katherine Ingraham
Katherine Ingraham
3 years ago

I was convinced by a contractor to use a Cabot solid color oil deck stain made to a Benjamin Moore color formula. The color came out very wrong and now there are two coats of it on my deck. I went back to the paint store and had the owner remix me another gallon but it came out the same. Then he tinkered with it for about an hour, adding blue and black, and said it was perfect. It obviously doesn’t match the swatch and now I’m stuck with another gallon of this Cabot oil stain that is not what I want. It looks like Benjamin Moore has an oil product called Impervo – I wonder why we didn’t just go with that. I wonder why Cabot can’t match the color?

Flo
Flo
3 years ago

Currently my deck has Glidden Endurance oil based semi transparent redwood deck stain on it. I am looking to restain but it appears that Glidden no longer makes this product. What prep do I need to do before I switch to a different brand of oil based semi transparent deck stain of same or similar color? The stain is pretty much intact.

Flo
Flo
3 years ago
Reply to  Flo

Here is a picture of what it looks like now. I haven’t done any prep or cleaning yet.

Deck photo 2.jpg
Craig
Craig
3 years ago

I have a two-level hardwood deck that is 25 years old. The wood is in good shape with peeling water based stain. If I strip the upper deck first, how should I protect the lower deck (next year’s project)? When I power wash the stripper off and it drips through, will it begin stripping the lower deck?

Also, is it a bad idea to use water based products on hard woods in a four season climate? They don’t seem to last. My deck is pau lope which is fine grained, much like mahogany.

Craig
Craig
3 years ago

Thank you for the quick reply! If it were your deck and clean up were not an issue, would you use the hardwood water based or oil based stain?

Arla Leonard
Arla Leonard
3 years ago

Sanded down a redwood picnic table, put linseed oil on it sanded it down again. Bought Cabot solid color acrylic deck stain, at the the same time I bought the linseed oil. I have been told that acrylic paint or stain does not adhere to linseed oil. I asked for a oil based paint or stain when I purchased both of the products, didn’t realize they gave me an acrylic base until today.

Arla Leonard
Arla Leonard
3 years ago

Sanded down a redwood picnic table put linseed oil on it. Bought Cabot solid color acrylic deck stain. Was told it was good for putting over the linseed oil. I didn’t read the can, saying “Acrylic”

Merriely Thomasson
Merriely Thomasson
3 years ago

Our fence is cedar and we had stained with water based stain. We would like to do it with an oil stain this time. Do we still have to remove all of water stain first? Will pressure washing do this?

vyoma
vyoma
3 years ago

What if I stain over the existing water based stain with an oil based stain. Let’s assume that it is a new stain and fairly happy with the color, and I want to get the benefit of oil based less maintenance feature, and I want to over coat it.

gay
gay
3 years ago

how to find out what has been used on our deck either water or oil

Tyler
Tyler
3 years ago

We are in process of getting bids to restore our 3 year old 500 square foot deck. We used Behr semi transparent water based stain, which has failed after the first year, mostly on the deck boards. One suggestion was to apply a semi solid stain (not clear which brand..or if water or oil based) to the pickets and railing without stripping due to the labor involved. The actual deck boards would be stripped and brightened, possibly sanded, and re-sealed using Armstrong-Clark semi transparent oil based stain. Will this work? I am mostly concerned about not stripping or sanding the railing/pickets and putting another product over the top with only a cleaning. Thank you for your input.

Peggy
Peggy
3 years ago

What is the prep to redo an oil-based semi solid stained deck with the same oil-based product?

Peggy
Peggy
3 years ago

The relatively new unstained deck was properly prepped and then coated with two coats of Benjamin Moore Armour Coat Semi-solid oil base stain. That was four yrs. ago. We would like to restain it again with the very same BM Armour Coat Semi Solid oil base stain. However, we have gotten mixed messages on how to prep the deck. The deck is still in great shape physically except for the fading color. We live in the south and the deck is exposed to our hot summers and high humidity, but a large portion of the deck has a canopy of two large crepe myrtle trees which gives some protection. Please help!!

Cory
Cory
3 years ago

Last year I used Defy Extreme on my deck. It is fading and some spots are getting bold exposing the wood. Why so soon ? Should I just stain again or I need to power wash and then stain again.

Cory
Cory
3 years ago

Should I use a cleaner as well when I pressure wash ? And can I use a different brand instead of Defy again ? Is Sikkens Cetol water or oil based ? Others ? Thank you .

Leah
Leah
3 years ago

I made a mistake and put Thompson’s water-based sealant on top of gray paint on an exterior deck. It is beading the water well (which was my goal, along with keeping mildew/algae better at bay), but turned the paint color a dirty yellow. Is there a way to remove the deck sealant without removing the paint? Or can I paint over that sealant again with a fresh coat of paint?

Emily Maple
Emily Maple
3 years ago

I purchased Cabot semi-transparent stain for my deck. The person doing the work has recommended a sealer such as Flood or Thompson’s on top at a later point. From what I am reading, that is not a good idea. Am I correct?

max
max
3 years ago

I have a carder deck with a oil based stain on it. I don’t like the stain as the floor feels oily and wet I have tried cleaning ect. I was thinking of removing the stain and redoing it with a water base stain not sure if this will fix the issue. To remove the oil based stain can I just sand or do I have to also use the chemical to remove it? Also what is the best way to apply the water base stain once the wood is ready?

Cory
Cory
3 years ago

I have 2 levels decks. One is high up and one very low 5″ off the ground . I want to use oil based stain . Which one is best for the lower level deck ? And then which one to use for upper one ? Thank you.

Cory
Cory
3 years ago

Oh. I think I read somewhere that for lower decks one should use a different stain because of the humidity and condensation . Thank you.

Steve
Steve
3 years ago

I have used Olympic Maximum redwood naturaltone semi transparent water based stain on my deck for years. I haven’t had great luck with it lasting over 2 years. Can I switch to a different brand and also switch to a semi-solid redwood water based stain to cover the semi-transparent stain ? And what would the prep be before applying the new stain ?
Thanks for any help

Steve
Steve
3 years ago

If I stay with semi-transparent just use a different brand water based stain can I just get away with pressure washing the deck and railings? Thanks for the help

Steve
Steve
3 years ago

Do you have a suggestion for the best stripper to remove a water based stain ?