The 7 Best Deck Stain Reviews and Ratings 4.8/5 (355)

7 Best Deck Stain Reviews for 2023

For more info, see our Deck Stain Facts section with over 150 simple Q&A articles that answer all the questions that you have regarding deck staining, cleaning, and prep.

Click to Read More

 

Top-Rated Deck Stain Reviews

See below for more in-depth reviews of the top-rated deck stains in 2023.

Best Deck Stain

Oil-Based 

Best Deck Stain

Water-Based

Best Solid Color

Deck Stain

Best Applying Wood Deck Stain

Questions on Which of the 7 Best Deck Stains to use?

Want personalized help? Post your questions below in the comments and we’ll be glad to guide you toward the best deck stain and sealer. Please include any pictures you may have and a brief history of the deck.

Our Professional Deck Stain Advice

Our favorite deck stains have always been penetrating semi-transparent and semi-solid stains. These stain types allow the wood grain to show, and if they truly soak into the wood grain, reapplying is easier down the road. The problem we have noticed in the last 5-10 years is that not all semi-transparent stains are penetrating. Many manufacturers have gone away with the true penetrating stains because of VOC laws and for profitability. These non-penetrating stains will dry on top of the wood and will be prone to peeling and failure while looking more like paint than a stain. Believe it or not, deck stains performed better 10-20 years ago with wearing and peeling than they do in 2023. There have been some major advancements though with UV protection in the past 5-10 years. Nano-particles of zinc oxides and improvements to trans-oxides have shown excellent UV resistance.

The good news is you can still find some quality deck stains in 2023 that will offer UV protection, penetrate deep into the wood grain, and highlight the natural beauty of the wood all while making the ease of reapplication a breeze down the road.


Top Deck Stain Reviews & Ratings

Each deck stain review that we do offers two rating types. Our DeckStainHelp.com review is based on our experience with the deck stain and the Consumer Star Ratings, which are based on actual customers’ experiences with using the same stain.

Deck Stain Star Ratings are based on these criteria:

  • Ease of Application
  • Appearance After Application
  • Preventing UV Graying at 2-Year Mark
  • Wear and Tear After 2 years
  • Color Shifting/Darken in Color (5 Star = No Darkening)
  • Preventing Mold/Mildew/Algae at 2-Year Mark

Listed below, we summarize our Best Deck Stain Ratings for the 2023 deck season, based on the criteria stated above. We have also broken them down into the top oil-based and water-based versions.

Top 4 Oil-Based Deck Stain Ratings
1. TWP 100 Series
2. Armstrong Clark Wood Stain
3. TWP 1500 Series
4. TWP Pro-Series Semi-Solid

Top 3 Water-Based Deck Stain Ratings
1. Restore-A-Deck Wood Stain
2. Defy Extreme Stain
3. Defy Hardwood/Cedar Stain

The 7 Best Deck Stain Ratings

1. TWP 100 Pro Series Stain Review

TWP 100 Deck Stain RatingsTWP 100 Series penetrates well into the wood, fades lightly in color, and holds up to wear and tear. We like that when it is time to redo the wood in 2-3 years, the TWP can be cleaned and re-coated or even removed with ease. This makes the reapplication process much easier. TWP 100 Series is only allowed in 35 States and cannot be used in Canada.
Stain Type: Penetrating Semi-Transparent Oil-Based. Full Curing Wood Stain.
Consumer Star Ratings:  4.5/5 (41)
DeckStainHelp.com Review (On a scale of 1-10): 8.69
See the Review Article Here: TWP 100 Series Review

2. Restore-A-Deck Semi-Transparent Wood Stain Review

Restore A Deck Wood Stain ReviewRestore-A-Deck Wood Stain can be applied to dry or damp wood. Applying to damp wood allows you the ability to prep and stain on the same day, saving you a tremendous amount of time. Restore-A-Deck Wood Stain is an advanced, water-based, semi-transparent stain formulation designed to penetrate deep into wood pores for maximum protection and longevity. Restore-A-Deck Wood Stain protects the wood from harmful UV rays and damage caused by water penetration.
Stain Type: Penetrating Semi-Transparent Water-Based. Full Curing Damp Application Stain.
Consumer Star Ratings:  4.6/5 (50)
DeckStainHelp.com Review (On a scale of 1-10): 8.625
See the Review Article Here: Restore-A-Deck Wood Stain Review

Restore-A-Deck Consumer Video Review

3. Armstrong Clark Wood Stain Review

Armstrong Clark Wood Stain RatingThe Armstrong Clark Wood stain has been a solid performer since we started reviewing and using it about 10 years ago. We really like how it penetrates deep into the wood grain and applies easily. Reapplication is simple with a good deck cleaner for the prep. One thing we have noticed is to make sure you do not overapply. You want the AC to soak completely into the wood. Compliant for all US states and Canada.
Stain Type: Penetrating Transparent, Semi-Transparent, Semi-Solid Oil-Based. Paraffin and Curing Oil Blend. Full Curing Stain.
Consumer Star Ratings:  4.4/5 (62)
DeckStainHelp.com Review (On a scale of 1-10): 8.5
See the Review Article Here: Armstrong Clark Stain Review

4. TWP Pro-Series Semi-Solid Wood Stain Review

TWP Semi-Solid Stain

What we like best about the TWP Semi-Solid Stain is that it is easy to apply, will be easy to prep and reapply when the time comes, and holds color very well from the UV. We are very excited and look forward to using the TWP Semi-Solid colors. Maximum UV protection and a much larger color palette is the top reason we will offer the TWP Semi-Solid to all of our customers. TWP Semi-Solid is only allowed in 35 States and cannot be used in Canada.
Stain Type: Penetrating Semi-Solid Oil-Based. Full Curing Stain.
Consumer Star Ratings: 4.9/5 (6)
DeckStainHelp.com Review (On a scale of 1-10): 8.50
See the Review Article Here: TWP Semi-Solid Series Review

5. TWP 1500 Series Stain Review

TWP 1500 Series RatingTWP 1500 Series is one of the better wood and decking stains and is one of our top choices. As contractors, we really like stains that penetrate deep into the wood and can be reapplied without sanding. TWP 1500 fits this and more by adding excellent UV and mold protection. Maintaining TWP every 2-3 years is easy. TWP 1500 is compliant for all US states, but not Canada.
Stain Type: Penetrating Semi-Transparent Oil-Based. Full Curing EPA Registered Stain.
Consumer Star Ratings:  4.6/5 (21)
DeckStainHelp.com Review (On a scale of 1-10): 8.5
See the Review Article Here: TWP 1500 Series Review

6. Defy Extreme Wood Stain Review

Defy Extreme Wood Stain RatingWe find the Defy Extreme Wood Stain to be one of the best-performing water-based deck stains on the market. The zinc oxide Nano-particles do double duty in preventing UV fading and preventing mold or mildew growth. The Defy Extreme penetrates into the wood grain extremely well for a water-based stain, resulting in a non-filming coating that is not prone to peeling or wear from traffic. We use the Defy Extreme on about 30-50 deck restorations every year in the Midwest and is one of our go-to brands. Compliant for all US states and Canada.
Stain Type: Penetrating Semi-Transparent Water-Based. Full Curing Stain with Nano-particles of Zinc Oxide.
Consumer Star Ratings:  4.1/5 (55)
DeckStainHelp.com Review (On a scale of 1-10): 8.47
See the Review Article Here: Defy Extreme Stain Review

7. Ready Seal Wood Stain Review

Ready Seal Stain Rating

Ready Seal Wood Stain contains the non-drying oil paraffin, which dives into the wood fibers and does not cure on the surface. There are many positives to paraffin stains, such as a user-friendly application and an even finish. The negatives can be poorer UV resistance and coverage rates with an oily finish that can stay on top of the surface. For an easy to apply even finish Ready Seal Wood and Deck Stain is a great choice. It may be necessary, however, to reapply every 12-18 months due to color loss.
Stain Type: Penetrating Transparent Paraffin Oil-Based. Non-Curing.
Consumer Star Ratings:  3.7/5 (56)
DeckStainHelp.com Review (On a scale of 1-10): 7.75
See the Review Article Here: Ready Seal Stain Review

Best Semi-Transparent Deck Stain Review

Best Deck Stain Ratings

Best Deck Stain Reviews

Restore-A-Deck Wood Stain can be applied to dry or damp wood. Applying to damp wood allows you the ability to prep and stain on the same day, saving you a tremendous amount of time. In 2018, our first full year of using the Restore A Deck stain, we had zero issues with performance and saved a tremendous amount of time with the ability to prep and stain on the same day. We will continue to offer the Restore A Deck Wood Stain as one of our go-to decking stains for the 2023 restoration season. The Restore A Deck Stains come in both Semi-Transparent and Solid Colors.

Best Semi-Solid Deck Stain Review

Best New Semi-Solid Stain for 2023: Available in 30 Custom Colors, the TWP® Semi-Solid Pro-Series will keep your wood beautiful, fresh, and looking new longer! The ease of application and maintenance will allow you to enjoy your investment for years to come. TWP® Semi-Solid Pro-Series provides a broad spectrum of weather protection, is water repellent, and aids in color retention. TWP® Semi-Solid Pro-Series resists water absorption that causes warping, cracking, splitting, and prevents freeze damage in colder climates.

Top Deck Stain Reviews Ratings Video – DeckStainHelp.com

Deck Stain Ratings & Review Photos

Popular Best Deck Stain Questions:

What deck stains will protect from UV graying?

Answer: To protect from UV graying the deck stain must be tinted. We prefer the semi-transparent stains as they will not mask or cover the wood but highlight the wood grain while providing UV protection.

What deck stains perform the best?

Answer: Our favorite deck stains have always been penetrating semi-transparent and semi-solid stains. These stain types allow the wood grain to show, and if they truly soak into the wood grain, reapplying is easier down the road.

What deck stain types can be cleaned and recoated as needed?

Answer: Penetrating deck stains are not prone to peeling and you can clean and reapply as needed. Deck stains that dry or film on top of the wood are much harder to maintain and prep when reapplying.

Can I use a deck stain on wood siding?

Answer: Absolutely! Deck stains are wood stains and work very well for wood fences, vertical wood siding and log cabins. They last even longer on vertical wood.

Additional Deck Stain Rating Questions

If you have questions on this review of deck stains, please ask below. For a more in-depth article on “What is The Best Deck Stain for Your Deck” see this article: The Best Deck Stain


Please Rate This. You may also post comments or ask questions below.

Top 7 Deck Stain Rating Results in 2023

5 314
4 28
3 4
2 2
1 5
0 2

Related Deck Stain Help Articles & Reviews

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

1.6K Comments
newest
oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Peter
Peter
5 days ago

I’m redoing our Redwood deck, it’s 30 years old, in good condition. These steps look good?

  1. Clean
  2. Brighten
  3. Sand
  4. Stain

Thanks!

Peter
Peter
5 days ago

Hey thanks for the reply! The last coating was water based, three years ago.

IMG_0057.jpeg
IMG_0056.jpeg
IMG_0055.jpeg
IMG_0053.jpeg
will D
will D
8 days ago

I’m sanding down and restaining my log home. Would you say these products work just as well on vertical as they do the decks they are reviewed for? thanks!

Lynne
Lynne
1 month ago

Hi – we are restaining our front porch in Priest River, Idaho. It faces south and is covered. Please advise on best stain to apply.
Thank you,
Lynne

Kim
Kim
1 month ago

Scott, I am about to stain a cedar fence. Do your ratings for deck stains apply for fence stains?

Bill
Bill
1 month ago

I have a new aluminum dock with cedar decking to be used from May to October in a northern New England fresh water lake and would like your recommendation for a water based stain/sealer. I am considering Restore-A-Deck with lots of tinting or Defy Extreme Solid or Semi-Solid Color with the nano-technology but am intrigued by the Defy Marine Seal. The dock has been installed since early June and I am planning to treat both sides (?) in late September. Thank you

carval123
carval123
1 month ago

I have a multilayered deck of pressure treated wood most of the deck being at least 25 years old with odd boards replaced over the years. The last application was of Cabot australian teak oil approximately 5 years ago.

in 2011 we had the deck power washed with a chemical and stained with

Benjamin Moore, ARBORCOAT semi solid stain:

Color; ABBEY BROWN

The brown semi solid stain still shows in some areas. How and with what products do I clean, strip and prepare the deck and what stain do you suggest. I would prefer a semi solid stain. thanks

Preston

20230804_111809.jpg
20230804_111854.jpg
20230804_111821.jpg
Karen
Karen
1 month ago

Im going a small side deck (new wood). I want to get a white washed look with lots of woodgrain showing through. I don’t want a solid white look. What would you suggest? Thanks.

Gary Rittmiller
Gary Rittmiller
2 months ago

I live in WY. we have harsh winters. we have a porch cedar deck. Only 2 yrs old. the product I first used started to peel in 1.5 yrs. the TWP, as well as some other brands sound good. Most of the railing is in fair condition. The deck is stain is nearly gone. I would like to maintain the natural color of the cedar if possible. What would u recommend?

Been Laden
Been Laden
2 months ago

Is there any chance you are going to review (without bias) other National brands of deck stain? There are lot of other ones out there that aren’t just the ones you sell on the online store you operate. I feel as though it would be a great benefit to the consumers. Specifically Olympic, Cabot, Thompson, Benjamin mohr.

Anthony
Anthony
2 months ago

I’ve built a new redwood deck and it has aged about 3 months now. I’ve sanded with 60 grit to remove the sap, tannin bleed, and even out the surface. I plan to clean the wood next using Behr wood cleaner to make sure any mill glaze and sanding dust is removed and then stain with Cabot ATO mahogany flame. Do I need to do anything after using the wood cleaner prior to staining other than letting it dry a couple days?

Margaret
Margaret
2 months ago

Have you tried Expert Stain and Seal, boasted as the best stain on facebook groups??

Glen
Glen
2 months ago

We want to re-stain a 20 year old composite deck that was stained 7 years ago. There is no peeling, but the first stain job was tacky for 2 weeks, What prep and coating products do you recommend?

Nicole
Nicole
2 months ago

The company that I hired to stain my deck has applied Behr Arborcoat on my deck. They had fist applied a coat of Sherwin Williams semi transparent stain but it turned out that it did not cover equally due to work that was not done properly. The Arborcoat is covering well but I happened to check the comments that it was not the best product and that it would peel easily.
I have not yet payed them and I really not know what to do. What it says on the can is that it is a sem transparent stain and that it is oil based. What should I do? I hired them because I wanted the work to be done professionally.

Michele Stute
Michele Stute
2 months ago

Deck is 5-6 years old treated lumber-1st application was Cabot Semi-Transparent and looked great. 2nd application 2-3 years ago used same product and seemed to not soak in as well. Getting ready to coat again but had peeling last time so have areas of bare wood and some areas of covered stain. Have cleaned/washed and am doing a light sanding. what product would be best. It is a brown stain used in the past.

Vlad
Vlad
2 months ago

Can I apply epoxy resin to oil base stain so it could last longer
Thank you

Ann
Ann
3 months ago

After reading your reviews, and a few others, for best deck stains I decided on Defy Extreme for a set of wood steps leading down into my yard from the shaded patio. Most of the steps get shade with the bottom one getting a bit of sun. After leaving to overwinter, I cleaned and brightened the day before staining and already saw an improvement. The light walnut shade of stain looked more like cedar… very orange…but my biggest problem was that I overapplied. I used the defy hand held brush and applied wet on wet but I could see it leaving behind small patches of puddling after the second coat. I repeatedly tried to empty the brush and brush over the patches but they just kept puddling. Is this what you meant by “difficult to apply” in the review? Can overapplication happen by applying second coat while first coat is still too wet? I’m going to be building a replacement kiln-dried deck in part sun, part shade and I would like a new product suggestion and/or application tips please. The sun shines through the trees for about two to three hours per day on small patches of the deck. I liked that defy would provide UV and anti-mildew protection and I liked that it was water based, low VOC. And I would probably go with a walnut color to prevent the orange look. Yikes this turned into an essay.

Doug
Doug
3 months ago

I have an exterior deck with pressure treated wood from that I stripped by sanding. The old stain was Cabot acrylic deck stain. However, I can’t completely remove some of the old stain in hard to reach spots. Do you think I should go ahead and try TWP 100 series or do I need to use the same product as before? If I use Cabot again, do I still need to clean the surface since their stain sits onto of the wood? I reside in Michigan Thank you in advance!

Doug
Doug
3 months ago

Thanks for getting back to me! The deck is in the shade now, which gives a darker appearance in the photo.But here you go:

IMG_3629.jpeg
IMG_3630.jpeg
IMG_3631.jpeg
Doug
Doug
3 months ago

To add, parts of the deck are wet due to rain this morning.

John Olesen
John Olesen
3 months ago

Would you recommend Cabot Gold? It leaves a nice satin sheen finish to the wood. I would be applying it to a pressure treated deck.

IMG_7880.jpeg
IMG_7882.jpeg
IMG_7833.jpeg
larry olson
larry olson
3 months ago

we let our new cedar wood deck set unstained for about 18 mths. we cleaned it with seal once cleaner then stained it two coats marine once sealer. 5 mths later water stains get on it from planter pots, in the direct sun area it has turned grey as if we had nothing on it. they sent us 4 new gallons but i’m afraid to use it again. whaat would be a good stain to use , in oregon.

Jim K
Jim K
4 months ago

I have thoughts about trying a product that implies
covering and filling in small 1/4” or less cracks on
my deck as an alternative.What are your thoughts about these types of products to use?

amy lassila
amy lassila
4 months ago

Hi there, thanks for all your information here.It’s much appreciated. You helped us two years ago when we restained our deck. We followed your advice using the cleaner and brightener + two coats of Defy Extreme Semi Transparent stain after letting the new wood season for a year in place unfinished. This is what it looks like today. Obviously a lot of wear where it gets the most traffic, but I’m curious if these photos look like what you’d expect 2 years in or if we need to try another approach.

Many thanks!

IMG_1752.jpg
IMG_1753.jpg
IMG_1751.jpg
IMG_1749.jpg
Amy lassila
Amy lassila
3 months ago

Hi again. We messed up. We sanded it down and forgot to brighten first. We put one coat of defy semi transparent and it doesn’t look great. What are our options here? Can we clean and brighten or is it too late.

amy lassila
amy lassila
3 months ago

Here you go. It’s not horrible, but I think it could be better. A lot of the wood is only 2 years old. Looking at these, does it seem like it’s a strip then brighten sort of situation? Thanks again for all your help on this.

IMG_2410.jpeg
IMG_2409.jpeg
Bob Higgins
Bob Higgins
4 months ago

Staining in Denver, Round 2!

Round 1 was spring 2020, with much help from you all at DeckStainHelp.com !

** We cleaned year-old untreated cedar with percarbonate mix, brightened with DEFY, and stained with Armstrong Clark

Round 2 is this spring
:
** We’ll clean and stain the same way …but do we need to do brightening again? Not sure if brightening is a ‘ do it every time you stain’ thing or not…

Thanks for any advice — and keep up the awesome work!

Tracey Begley Croak
Tracey Begley Croak
5 months ago

I  used RAD stripper followed by RAD brightener with light power washing. Then coated with Penofin marine oil.
Followed same steps one year ago and my deck looked great. This year it is splotchy with light and dark spots.
Ipe installed 2010
400 square feet
Do I need to strip/light sand/brighten and then apply a semitransparent stain or Ipe oil?

BF59BCF7-FF4B-460E-815C-8681060AFF2C.jpeg
655CDB62-F7F5-4197-B580-F8DA5F2C09EB.jpeg
903F1441-7F75-4728-9D89-C62E7C4E2453.jpeg
walton
walton
5 months ago

I recently had my deck stained with Sherwin Williams Dock and Deck solid stain and do not like the color. Can I apply a different color over this new stain?

Sherry
Sherry
5 months ago

Hi, 2nd time staining deck and ran out. Still need more coverage. Is it OK to add a different kind/color of stain? Used Thompsons waterseal

Iris
Iris
5 months ago

weill restore a deck get wax that was in thompson sealant. I tried their product and I am having a hard time removing this wax that’s in the wood.

Cassie W
Cassie W
5 months ago

Looking to stain PTP deck that was installed just over a year ago. It’s under a tree, doesn’t get much direct sun, and we are in hot, humid, muggy Maryland. We have the RAD brightener cleaner product ready to go, but can’t decide if we should use oil-based or water-based. Main concerns are mildew and ease of application, we definitely want semi-transparent. Thanks!

John Halme
John Halme
5 months ago

Hello Scott

Great site based on real world experience.

We are building a new home in Western Washington state with Doug Fir Timbers and vertical Cedar channel siding.

1) What is your recommendation for first treatment? TWP 100 Pro Series or something else? We have had good luck with TWP on log rail fences in the past.

2) If TWP how long should we wait to apply it?

3) How does TWP100 compare to Outlast Q8 Log Oil?

John

Tara Buhr
Tara Buhr
5 months ago

I used defy semi transparent stain on my deck floor. We are in Oregon, and our deck gets a few hours of sun a day, otherwise is fairly shady. Some areas get very wet during the rainy season.

Last year I applied the defy, but it was towards the end of the year, it got cold, and it got rainy. I think I was at the end of required temperature for application, and it rained within 2 days off applying. The stain peeled and is wearing away in heavy rain spots. Do you think that I applied it to thick? or do you think the stain didn’t have time to adhere very well d/t the weather? or both?

I am trying again with better weather this spring. My question is do I have to strip and brighten again before re-application since it is peeling in some spots?

Also, I am noticing our nails are turning the deck black around the nail site. My other question is, obviously a solid stain would cover that, but I am hesitant to stain my deck solid since we get so much inclement weather. Advice appreciated 🙂

I still have plenty of semi transparent stain left over, but I would be willing to explore new options. Do you think the defy is good for the type of weather I live in? or would an oil based be better?

Gina Miklas
Gina Miklas
5 months ago

Hello! Last summer I removed the solid stain, cleaned and brightened with RAD then stained with Armstrong/Clark semi transparent oil. After going through the winter some of the higher traffic areas seems to have worn off. Do I clean/brighten then stain again this year? Are both steps necessary? I will be using the same stain. Thank you!

372BD300-C8F8-478F-A50C-DF5BF0770ADC.jpeg
1B292C26-3715-44DE-8F03-F14626F605B3.jpeg
Ray
Ray
5 months ago

Hi, I have a batu hardwood. I have tried ipe oil as well as penofin hardwood stain for the wood and the stain barely lasts a year and fades horribly especially on the horizontal surfaces (decks). My yard has a ton of the batu wood (fencing, decks, etc…). One of the decks is also a pool deck. I’m looking for a new type for this hardwood as the penofin isnt’ working great. I really want that Brazilian hardwood color to stay and it fades pretty badly. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Rachel
Rachel
5 months ago

Is there a truly penetrating semi transparent white stain that you recommend? Don’t want flaking in a few years. We have a small horizontal privacy wall that extends above our deck benches that I would prefer be a distinctly different color from the rest of the deck which will be a more natural wood color. (Really don’t want gray.) It’s new pressure treated pine that has finished curing. Location: Texas

20220802_180824.jpg
Len
Len
6 months ago

I’d like your suggestions for a 25 by 40 deck with 15 8 foot wide steps that is 5 years old. Never stained. Faces the South and has full sun all year. Do I power wash, use some type of cleaner, stain. You have a lot of advice but would like to get your suggestions for my situation for prep and stain…Restore A Deck maybe?

jean tessmer
jean tessmer
8 months ago

Scott have you ever used a ceiling drywall sander to sand decks?

jean
jean
8 months ago

have you every used deck restoration penetrating stain. how does it compare to restore a deck penetrating stain?

Linda
Linda
9 months ago

Can you email me why you removed my added comments? are you paid by the brands you review and write about?

Farrah Romeo
Farrah Romeo
9 months ago

Im in florida with a deck wide open to the elements, lots of rain and sun. New deck built about 4-5 mo ago. Ive been told water-based is the way to go by a deck stain company. Any reccomendations on which product to use?

Farrah Romeo
Farrah Romeo
9 months ago

Im trying to hire someone to do this work. I will have them use one of these products. A couple companies insist they should sand the wood to get best results and longevity. Another one says they wouldn’t sand. Is sanding OK, good idea, bad idea?

Nik
Nik
10 months ago

Hi Love this website! I’m switching from Penofin to Restore a Deck for a wood door on a covered porch. I plan to use a cleaner and brightener before the Restore a Deck application. I have Penofin brand cleaner and brightener on hand already– would it be ok to use them and then apply Restore a Deck, or is there some reason I would need to get Restore a Deck brand cleaner and brightener before using their stain?

Nik
Nik
10 months ago

Two pctures of door

PXL_20221115_192317412.jpg
PXL_20221115_192345919.jpg
Christina Gerwinat
Christina Gerwinat
10 months ago

I just bought a house with a 17 year old deck which was stained at some point with a semi solid but wasn’t maintained. After reading reviews I wanted to buy TWP semi solid, but unfortunately I can’t afford it as their deck stain calculator indicates that I’d need 15 gallons since my deck surface alone is 1200 sq feet! A local guy who does deck restoration swears by Shark Skin semi solid by Cloverdale which is sold by Redda here in Oregon. It’s primarily sold in Canada and the western US (OR, WA, CA, MT, ID, & AK) so you might not have heard of it, but I wanted to ask your opinion…

Thanks in advance!

Jason V
Jason V
11 months ago

Moved in our house 4 years ago, it was built in 2001 and pretty sure the deck was original, so 21 years old. We’ve done nothing to it since moving in. Not sure what the stain on it is. I want to bring it back to life and extend its life. What would you recommend in terms of stain? I’ll repost if need pictures without it raining. Thanks!

Jason V
Jason V
11 months ago

Scott,

Here are pictures. It rained a bit ago so the wood is darker than typical. The stain on it appears to be oil based as there is no peeling at all, it is totally soaked within the wood, but i’m not sure. A contractor looked at our deck yesterday and recommended SW SuperDeck product, but your reviews indicate it is a poor product. For the $$ it costs, I want it done right and with a good product (do it once do it right!). We are located in Northern Illinois if that impacts what product to use. The deck is on the south side of the house and 2/3 of it gets baked in the sun, and 1/3 is shaded. Thank you for your time and recommendations.

Jason

20221012_094039.jpg
20221012_094055.jpg
20221012_094114.jpg
20221012_094158.jpg
Jason V
Jason V
11 months ago

Thank you? Just to clarify:

  1. I don’t know what stain is on there now. But your saying whatever it is on there needs to be stripped first?
  2. The TWP 1500 Series website says coverage is 150 to 250 sq.ft., based on your experience how much would you estimate cover is when purchasing?

Thanks again, super helpful!

Sharon M
Sharon M
11 months ago

I live in Alabama. My porch is covered but about 2/3 full sun each day. Last May we prepped and applied one coat of Thompson Semi Transparent deck stain.Now the 3/4 exposed to sun has faded and looks worn and splotchy. The other 1/4 still looks ok. Do I need to strip and restain or can I put another coat directly over the whole porch?

Sharon M
Sharon M
11 months ago
Reply to  Sharon M

Here are my pictures.

92890375-8D18-4F63-BE11-D81169B489B1.jpeg