Update 2019 for Why Deck Stain Cannot be Shiny
We here at DeckStainHelp.com are proud to be the internet’s number one reference for all things wood deck restoration related. As before, we do not recommend the use of polyurethane stains on outdoor decks as they will peel. We always appreciate your input and questions, so feel free to leave a comment below.
Peeling Deck Varnish
Unlike some wood stain finishes on hardwood floors that have a reflective or shiny finish, most exterior deck stains are not meant to be shiny. A deck stain works best when it is applied to a clean wood surface. This allows the deck stain to penetrate deep into the wood pores to ensure a solid wall of protection against sun and water damage. The amount of deck stain that is applied depends on different factors like wood age, condition, and porosity. Not all wood surfaces will absorb the same amount of deck stain when they are being refinished.
It is important to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for applying a deck stain. Some deck stains will be sufficient with one coat while others may be applied in several coats for maximum protection. A deck stain that has cured or dried to a shiny finish most likely indicates an over application problem. When deck stain is applied correctly it penetrates the wood giving it a natural finish. Most deck stains can enhance the natural beauty of the wood even without a shiny finish.
When deck stain is over applied, the excess stain that was not absorbed by the wood remains on top the surface and dries to a crusty shiny finish. This problem results in peeling, flaking, cracking and an overall decrease in appearance. You might think more is better when it comes to applying deck stain but that is not the case. A shiny finish can lead to premature failure of the deck stain product.
To avoid over-applying deck stain so it does not turn out shiny and end up failing prematurely work in small areas at a time. It is best to coat one whole board from end to end and wait several minutes for the deck stain to penetrate the wood. Try not to apply stain on a hot day or in direct sunlight as this can alter the absorption rate and dry time. Once the stain has had time to absorb, wipe away or back brush any excess stain puddles or runs before coating the next board. Applying only as much deck stain as the wood can absorb will result in a better finish ensuring the deck stain is not shiny when it cures. This will give you a longer lasting finish.
Any Questions on this Topic? Please Ask Below!
Used Olympic Elite Solid Stain and Sealer in coffee… doesn’t look like the color AT ALL. Followed instructions for 2 coats. It looks a little shiny (not in spots, evenly all over). Will this dull down? Should we be concerned it will peel?
The sheen should dull down. Not sure about the peeling. Only time will tell.
How do you remove the Sheen and tackiness
Depends on the brand and type of stain you used?
After careful and rigorous prep including deck wash, brightener, dry time, and sanding, we spent the whole of yesterday afternoon staining our old deck with Valspar Semi-Transparent Stain & Sealer (water-based) in a dark brown color.
The directions said that rolling was an appropriate way to apply to the deck boards, so we did so with “deck” rollers and had one dry roller specifically for back-rolling any excess stain. For the railings, we used a “stain mitt”, which is pretty much what it sounds like (dip mitt in stain, wrap hand around railing).
We ended up with an over-application that just looks like paint (too much/opaque coverage), and is uneven and shiny (but thankfully, not sticky). It’s kind of blinding when the sun shines on it. It’s been about 24 hours and I’m considering wiping over it with lacquer thinner to try to remove the excess and the shine – is that a terrible idea? We spent so many hours prepping and staining this thing, I’m beyond depressed!
Any advice would be highly appreciated!
Wiping it down will not work with a water-based stain. Sorry but you are stuck with this opaque looking stain.
We have a shiny deck and didn’t mean to. How can we fix it!
Depends on the brand of stain and type of stain you used? Pictures would help as well.
How can I get rid of a smaller area of shiny decking so it will match the rest of the deck please? Thank you
Try using some lacquer thinner.
I have a Merbau deck that is about 5 years old . When I reapply a coat it is shiny in some parts and stays that way but literally right next to the shiny part there will be dull patches . It used to look fantastic but now is very patchy . I must admit I have been guilty of the thinking more is better . I guess now its coming back to bite me in the butt . I don’t see an easy solution . Do you think I have to sand the entire deck back to bare wood ? I have been using a timber oil product by Intergrain .
The only way to fix this is to sand it all off down to the bare wood.
Would going over the whole deck with a matte clear deck finish help with making shiny spots dissapear ? or probably make it worse?
No. Make it worse.
My deck needs to be re-stained. I'm planning on using the same color, so am not really concerned with stripping the old finish. However, I have one small section that has a very slight shine to the old finish. I'm afraid that this would be an area where the new stain would not fully penetrate. It's a very slight shine, so what would the best way to eliminate that shine before re-staining. Can I do a light application of stripper only one that area?
Spot stripping will not work. What stain are you using. Best to follow the advice that the stain brand suggest for reapplying.
By same color I assume you mean same brand as well? If switching brands you will need to strip, unless you are applying a solid color stain.